MyFox
 

Ned Hibberd's Blog

by hibberd from Houston, Texas

Last Post 4 hours Ago


When people talk about the "good old days," I doubt many are referring to this:

Speed Limit Changes

 

In 1974, as the oil crisis raged, federal law changed America's maximum speed limit to 55.

 

And by and large, there it remained, until Congress and President Clinton eliminated national speed limits in 1995.

 

But with gas prices surpassing four bucks across the country, some are calling for a return to the "double nickel" on speed limit signs.

 

For more on their reasons, visit Drive55.org here: http://www.drive55.org/  The bottom line is, they assert a savings of 20% - 50% in fuel economy.

 

My question to you is: could you drive 55?  How expensive would gas have to get before you'd consider reducing your speed?

 

What if a 55 MPH speed limit were aggressively enforced, with big-money traffic tickets?  Would you obey then?

 

Or is 55 just too slow for 2008, regardless of the reasons it might make economic or environmental (or even safety) sense?

 

Ned

 

26 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 26
Page 1 of 3
1
Last
yahyamoro read my blog
Jun 11, 2008 | 6:55 AM

IF YOU DON'T WANT TO GET RUN OVER OR RUN INTO BY SOME OF THE MANIACS WE SHARE THE ROAD WITH , I DON'T SUGGEST IT ... THEY DRIVE 55 MPH IN THE SCHOOL ZONE !

Writing_With_Power read my blog view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 7:02 AM

Saw the report and sad for me, I agree with the song, I cant drive 55

Texasex read my blog view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 7:20 AM

I admit I drive slower to conserve. When the folks who have a lead foot and insist driving 80 or so then they DONT have the right to complain about paying too much for gas.

kagua2 read my blog
Jun 11, 2008 | 7:24 AM

I agree with yah. I drive a Mustang and people bear down on me in an effort to get me to speed up.

Gottaluvit read my blog view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 9:28 AM

If we ALL drove the posted speed right now we would probably save a lot in fuel. They DON'T enforce the laws now. I don't think 55 would make any difference. All that would do is get a lot of people hit in the A$$. Houston is not ready for 55 when a good share of them are doing 80 on the toll way now. Everyone is in way too big of a hurry. They blow by me in school zones.....no cops in sight. I guess safety just doesn't matter in our town. B-safe and slow down.

Native_American view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 10:11 AM

The problem with thinking slower speed limits will save gas is you're comparing the average cars of the early/mid 70's to todays cars. There's NO comparing the two.
Back then it was dang near impossible to buy a car with "overdrive" (a final gear ratio of less than 1:1) and today it's dang near impossible to buy a car that doesn't have overdrive.
Every engine will have a point of maximum efficiency, normally around it's peak torque but not always. At this point the engine will require LESS throttle to maintain speed and thus burn less fuel. Todays cars are geared from the factory for maximum efficiency at a certain speed. Slight variations can effect it (tire size changes are the most common) but normally not much. However, a 15 to 20 MPH change can and will effect it quite a bit. Ex: A bogging car will require more throttle to maintain speed and will always seem to be on the verge of down shifting (if it doesn't constantly) and it will also be more prone to pinging from the lack of octane requiring the owner to either buy a higher grade of gas or have the car re-tuned to run with less ignition timing or a fatter fuel curve to prevent engine damage.
It will be interesting how many of the classroom smart geniuses will try and tell all of the hands-on mechanics and engineers how changing speed limits will save the world TONS of fuel. Especially since they've really stuck their proverbial foot in their mouths when they released the data showing dairy cows are worse polluters than the average automobile..

xlacious
Jun 11, 2008 | 11:35 AM

Power (and therefore fuel) required to overcome wind resistance increases exponentially as speed increases no matter what kind of engine, drive-train, gear ratio, car, motorcycle, compression ratio, fuel, diploma or PhD you have.

Native_American view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 1:03 PM

xlacious,
At typical highway speeds, wind resistance isn't a major factor at all!! Especially when we're only talking a 10-20 MPH change. Airflow is a different science in-and-of itself. If you've ever been involved in any wind tunnel testing you would see every vehicle forms a pressure wedge in front of it that air begins to flow smoothly over. Secondly you'd realize that EVERY car/truck/SUV basically acts like an airplane wing (longer flow path over the top than the bottom) which creates lift. That's why even newer cars are fitted with air dams under the core support to "spoil" that effect and add stability to the vehicle. More importantly since cars don't have much of a grill these days it creates a high pressure area in front of the radiator/AC condenser to aid in cooling efficiency.
Testing done in NHRA ProStock has also shown little to no effect in actual pressure differentials using different hood scoop shapes and sizes. However, at speeds over 200 MPH they have seen a difference in overall vehicle wind resistance so the actual size and shape of the scoops have gotten smaller. Mind you the findings of SLIGHT differences in wind resistance at 200 MPH would equal -0- difference to a vehicle at typical highway speeds.. The same findings have been made in NASCAR, Winston Cup, USAC, and several other sanctioned bodies.
I would much rather concentrate my efforts to making the vehicle run more efficiently than worry about the difference in wind resistance at 10-20 MPH. A difference that would probably compare to having a single typical 8-10 yr old in the back seat (ad

Native_American view my photos
Jun 11, 2008 | 1:04 PM

Additional vehicle weight.

yo_unbaleeva_bull read my blog
Jun 11, 2008 | 8:15 PM

I am not complaining about the cost of fuel and I will not drive 55 on our state highways...

...unless...

...it is the law.

Page 1 of 3
1
Last


Write your comment below:




hibberd

I've been at Fox 26 since 1988, covering stories in every nook and cranny of Houston...and beyond. Even so, I never cease to be amazed...

Member Since: 1/15/2007